• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Amici Grill and Pizzeria

Amici Grill and Pizzeria, located at 3808 Ridge Rd, Highland, IN, offers a welcoming family atmosphere and exceptional customer service. This charming eatery is renowned for its mouthwatering dishes, from the famous Cajun chicken pasta to delectable gyros pizza and generous salads. Guests rave about the crispy thin-crust pizza, enhanced by flavorful house dressing and ample toppings. Each dining experience is elevated by the friendly staff, ensuring quick service and a cozy vibe. With a diverse menu and reasonable prices, Amici Grill and Pizzeria is a delightful destination for both dine-in and takeout, perfect for families and friends alike.

Amici Grill and Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings

Juan Mendoza
Juan Mendoza

We were in the area, so we decided to stop at the place to eat lunch. Staff was super friendly and the restaurant has a nice family atmosphere. Food was delicious. We ordered the Greek Fries and the chicken wings as appetizers. Both dishes were delicious, but the star of the day was the chicken Cajun pasta. The dish was delicious, a tiny bit spicy (which was the best part of the dish), but the flavor was amazing. The pizza was also delicious. Prices were not that high. I will definitely go back to this place soon.

Sandra Cash
Sandra Cash

Food is always good. Services was 10/10! It was not packed. If you go definitely try the gyros pizza and the garlic knots with Alfredo and marinara sauces. That Alfred sauce is so good. The Amici margarita was great too!!

Rich Woodrick
Rich Woodrick

Dined in on a Saturday evening. It was pretty quiet in the place. Ordered the Garden Salad and a 14" thin crust Supreme pizza. The salad was enough for 3 to 4 people. I thought the crotons were perfect. Not hard, but crispy and flavorful. Loved how the onions and tomatoes were cut into larger pieces. The house dressing made this salad very flavorful. I loved it. The pizza was FIRE!! The edge of the crust had that crispy crust that you want. It was so good!! Loved how they put oragano out on the table along with Parmesan cheese and red peppers. I will definitely come back when I'm in the area for a concert at the casino.

Sade Love
Sade Love

My server was Leah. 10/10 was efficient and provided great service. Food was hot and presentable. She was honest and recommended a great appetizer. The atmosphere was welcoming.

Steven
Steven

Great place for dine in or carry out. Food is always very good and service is fast and friendly. Have tried every gyro around this area and this may very well be my favorite. Good pasta dishes, homemade desserts and probably one of the best ham hoogies also. Very busy at lunch time. Don't forget the fries !

Sophie Marie
Sophie Marie

Me and my fiance love coming here! The service is always incredible. Everyone is so kind!! And they are always playing great playlists. Food is good & fresh. I love their drinks----I recommend the dirty martini and the Peach Sangria if you are looking for something sweeter.

Holy spirt tell a vision
Holy spirt tell a vision

Little higher than what I remember due to inflation. But just like I remember. Before I got kicked out of mansard Apts. Man I miss Indiana. This was one of my go 2 spots before a big tournament at horseshoe or if I got knocked out early. I may have came here to pick my wounds with their delicious grub. Support generational wealth! Support local business! It's the American Way. Shalom unto all that hear this word .

Vee
Vee

On 5.30.25 my 29 yo son services were held at Hillside, after the food ran out I suggested Amici’s ( I had 1st tried a week prior) & our Server was ERIC! He put tables together to accommodate over 20 people, he was attentive, patient, professional, courteous, empathetic & very kind! The food IS/WAS AMAZING, I will ONLY buy my pizza from there from this day forward and the chicken tenders are delicious! I WANT TO THANK ERIC FOR HIS KINDNESS, in today’s society customer service is horrible, establishments are nasty and ghetto. I was hurting from my loss, to encounter such an awesome young man gave me hope in humanity and I personally tipped him really good. He deserved it, he was an example of an AWESOME HUMAN BEING! The prices are good, the food is good & ERIC IS GREAT!!!!!

Location

Welcome to Amici Grill and Pizzeria, where culinary excellence meets a warm, family-friendly atmosphere! Located at 3808 Ridge Rd, Highland, IN 46322, this charming eatery invites you to indulge in a diverse menu of delicious offerings, ranging from tantalizing appetizers to mouthwatering pizzas.

One of the standout features of Amici is its commitment to quality service, as highlighted by numerous customers. Juan Mendoza describes the staff as "super friendly," setting the stage for a welcoming dining experience. He particularly enjoyed the savory chicken Cajun pasta, a dish praised for its right amount of spice and remarkable flavor. The Greek fries and chicken wings served as excellent appetizers, showing that every part of the meal is crafted with care.

For those looking to try something unique, Sandra Cash raves about the gyros pizza, paired delightfully with garlic knots and dipping sauces—an essential recommendation for newcomers. The restaurant’s signature Amici margarita has also earned high marks, making it the perfect companion to any meal.

Rich Woodrick shares his enthusiasm for the 14" thin crust Supreme pizza, noting the perfectly crispy edges and generous toppings. His fondness for the Garden Salad—ample enough for multiple servings—showcases the restaurant's focus on quality fresh ingredients and presentation. Each bite is enhanced with flavorful house dressing and crispy croutons, embodying the attention to detail that defines Amici.

Whether you're dining in or taking out, Amici Grill and Pizzeria promises fast, friendly service. From the time you step in to when you take your last bite, the experience is assured to be memorable. Steven highlights their commitment to quality by stating it’s the best gyro he’s tasted in the area, along with homemade desserts and delectable pasta dishes, suggesting there's something for everyone on the menu.

In summary, Amici Grill and Pizzeria is more than just a meal; it’s a delightful experience surrounded by good vibes and even better food. So why wait? Plan your visit today by calling +1 219-923-7300 and discover for yourself why this restaurant continues to win the hearts—and appetites—of its patrons!